To be a proponent of universal healthcare right now is only marginally more difficult than, say, being a New Jersey politician. Optimistic political newbies of the “Progressive” persuasion entered the healthcare debate with dreams of nationwide, single-payer healthcare. That was quickly downgraded by Hope’s anathema, “pragmatism,” to a public option, which was traded for lukewarm feelings about some kind of public-private hybrid model (with mandates).
Then, the public-private option was taken hostage by six moderate Senators, including ancillary Republicans, the “Blue Dog” Senators, who raised at least $1 million from the health and insurance sectors combined over the course of their respective careers. Meanwhile, President Obama’s August deadline looms in the distance. Majority Leader Harry Reid expressed concern on Thursday that the Senate might not be able to provide for Americans’ healthcare needs by the target date because the Senators have their own needs, namely the need to go on vacation where they will enjoy their government-provided universal healthcare coverage.
I interviewed Wendell Potter, the former top public relations official for CIGNA, one of the nation’s largest insurers, about the kind of influence the healthcare industry wields over members of Congress, and the need for healthcare reform in America. While serving CIGNA, Potter was part of a group charged with discrediting Michael Moore’s film, Sicko, which he now calls an “honest film.” He is now a whistleblower for Big Health, an industry that he blames for leaving millions of Americans uninsured, under-insured, and misinformed.
Potter’s change of heart began while he was visiting family in upper-east Tennessee, near the border of Virginia. It was there that Potter picked up a local newspaper and saw that a health fair was being held in Wise, Virginia by a group called Remote Area Medical (RAM). Curious, Potter got into his car and drove to Wise. He had no idea what to expect, but assumed there would be doctors and nurses conducting general health-screenings. Nothing could have braced Potter for what he saw when he reached the Wise County fairgrounds.
It was almost like being hit by lightening to see what I saw. There were long, long lines, people standing in line, sitting in a long line — in the rain — waiting to get free care that was being provided by volunteer doctors and nurses.
Today is RAM’s tenth annual expedition in Wise, Virginia, and things have gotten worse. The volunteers are expecting 20 percent more attendees than last year, and citizens were already setting up camp outside the fairgrounds as early as Tuesday. (Click here to read my interview with RAM founder, Stan Brock.) Things are worse now, but they were still very bad back when Potter first attended a RAM expedition where he stood in the rain and watched poor people queue in animal stalls for their chance to see doctors. Something, Potter decided, was wrong.
He left CIGNA shortly after his trip to Wise, Virginia. In June, Senator Jay Rockefeller invited Potter to testify about the underhanded practices of the private healthcare industry before the Senate Commerce Committee (his full testimony can be viewed here).
But this all occurred before President Obama revealed his public-private plan. I wanted to know what a former healthcare insider thought of Obama’s option, and what Potter thought of the dismissal of a universal healthcare plan. “All of us deserve access to care, so I think universal health care should be this country’s goal just like other developed countries,” says Potter, though he doesn’t see the solution coming from the federal government. Though he fully supports a public option, Potter believes every man, woman, and child should have access to healthcare, and the only way to make that happen is with universal healthcare. However, Potter is optimistic that America might follow the Canada model for coverage.
In Canada, it began at the provincial level. I think it could possibly happen in this country at the state level. There have been a number of states that have looked at implementing a single-payer system, including California. In fact, California lawmakers have twice voted for a single-payer system that Governor Schwarzenegger has vetoed. And the state of Pennsylvania, where I live, is seriously considering a single-payer option, and it has a lot of Republican support. A lot of Republicans have signed on as sponsors. So it’s something that could develop at the state level, and more than likely will be the only way it can happen in the United States.
Canadian care is delivered privately by doctors and hospitals just like we have it delivered here in America. A single-payer system in America would behave the same way. Potter emphasizes, “you would have publicly funded, privately delivered care.” Not a government bureaucrat standing between a doctor and patient anywhere.
The main obstacle standing between Americans and universal healthcare is, of course, the private healthcare industry. The reason the “universal” option disappeared almost immediately from the conversation on the Hill is because Big Health flexed its muscle. Groups like “the health insurance industry, and like big PHRMA, and the pharmaceutical industry, and even the American Medical Association,” Potter says are “looking out for the best interest of their membership. In other words, the health insurance trade group is looking out for the best interest of insurance companies. They’re, ultimately, not looking out for the best interest of the individual residents and citizens of the United States.”
The lesson was made painfully clear this week when six Senators, who are famous for sucking the teat of the private healthcare industry, successfully delayed the healthcare debate. Sadly, that’s business as usual, Potter admits.
Here’s how that works: The industry can pretty much rely on almost every Republican member of Congress. It seems, in my view, that they all are pretty much- if not “in-the-pocket” – certainly ideological allies of the insurance industry. So the way it’s working is that the industry knows that they’ve got those votes, so what they’re doing is devoting their resources right now to the Conservative Democrats, the so-called “Blue Dog” Democrats, any moderates who might be left in Congress – they’re targeting them and trying to persuade them to see the world from their point of view.
Persuading key conservative Democrats to “see the world from their point of view” can include extremely generous campaign contributions. When the healthcare industry isn’t busily buying the influence of Congress representatives, they engage in heavy public disinformation campaigns and dump sick people from their rolls in order to make more money.
Potter recently wrote an article titled “Health Care Industry Adopts Big Tobacco’s PR Tactics” in which he details how the healthcare industry uses the same public relations firm that Big Tobacco has used over the years. “One of the favorite tactics of both the insurance industry and the tobacco industry is to set up front groups they fund, but that funding is not known to the public, to communicate the industry’s points of view through these front groups,” he says. These groups always have very altruistic names like the “Health Benefits Coalition,” and their mission is to scare people away from additional government involvement in the healthcare system, say in the form of universal coverage or a public option.
Another Big Health-Big Tobacco strategy is to set up third-party advocates. “They’ll look for individuals, and other groups that might have some connection either through business or ideology with the health insurance industry, and they’ll feed those groups and those individuals with talking points to make sure that they have a lot of people and a lot of organizations expressing their points of view,” says Potter.
This explains why the same handful of anti-public option buzzwords seemed to ubiquitously saturate the media: “Slippery slope toward Socialism.” “Government bureaucrat between you and your doctor.” “Rationing.” These are not grassroots words adopted by citizens who fear universal healthcare. These are PR-molded buzzwords that are disseminated to satellite groups whose sole purpose is to kill a public option.
Recently, it was reported that President Obama has hosted at least 27 meetings with some of the most influential private health-industry executives in the country including representatives from the American Hospital Association, PHARMA, the AMA, UnitedHealth, Kaiser Foundation, Merck, HealthNet, and Pfizer. That kind of access is normal for Big Health, Potter stresses, which helps to illustrate the kind of daunting force Americans are battling in their fight to get affordable healthcare. “The industry is so rich, so resourceful, so powerful…They have hired lobbyists, who used to be members of the Congress, or the Senate, or staff members on Capitol Hill, they have tremendous access, and they have made contributions to members of Congress over many years, so they’ve got a cumulative records of making contributions – essentially buying influence on Capitol Hill. It’s enormous,” Potter says. Max Baucus is a perfect example of this. Famous for accepting vast donations from Big Health, Baucus also has former staff members who now work in the health insurance industry as lobbyists. Surely, one perk of being a former staffer to Max Baucus is that they now have the ear of their old boss when Big Health needs something from Congress.
The problem can’t fix itself when Big Health remains a beast without compassion, concerned only with its bottom line. Things are so dire now that the healthcare companies have resorted to “dumping the sick,” and screwing small businesses. If you buy your insurance, meaning an employer doesn’t provide the insurance for you, the industry refers to that as purchasing insurance from the “individual market.” When the insurance company starts to see “individual market” claims coming in, they go through them and look for any kind of “preexisting condition” that could possibly disqualify you, so they don’t have to pay the claim. A preexisting condition can literally mean anything: high blood pressure, high cholesterol, or even acne, Potter tells me.
This kind of “purging” of the sick has gotten so widespread that many small businesses can no longer afford to provide insurance for their employees. “In 1993, 61 percent of small businesses were offering coverage to their employees. By 2008, it had dropped down to 38 percent,” he says.
Even the temporarily healthy are paying a hefty price for their coverage. A worrying trend that Potter observed while working at CIGNA was the move toward “consumer-driven plans,” a euphemistic term for shifting the financial burden from insurance company to consumer. These plans feature high deductibles and are really just another way for the insurance companies to make money from the suffering of their consumers.
Potter is unequivocal about who is to blame for the disinformation and governmental bribery behind the killing of universal coverage and the slow suffocation of the public option: “I saw that the insurance companies were directly contributing through their behavior, through their practices, to the growing number of the uninsured, and also to the growing number of people who are under-insured.”
Unfortunately, it’s difficult to get government representatives to care in the same way, particularly when their hands are shoved in the Big Health cookie jar. The universal option is dead in the water. The public option may be next, at least if Big Health has any say in the matter.
Wendell Potter’s blog can be read here.
Allison Kilkenny is the co-host of Citizen Radio and a contributing writer to Huffington Post, Alternet.org, and The Nation. Her essay “Youth Surviving Subprime” appears in the book, Meltdown: How Greed and Corruption Shattered Our Financial System and How We Can Recover alongside essays by Ralph Nader, Joseph Stiglitz, Barbara Ehrenreich, and Naomi Klein. She blogs at allisonkilkenny.com.











LEAD, FOLLOW, OR GET OUT OF THE WAY. (Thomas Paine)
We have the 37th worst quality of healthcare in the developed world. Conservative estimates are that over 120,000 of you dies each year in America from treatable illness that people in other developed countries don’t die from. Rich, middle class, and poor a like. Insured and uninsured. Men, women, children, and babies. This is what being 37th in quality of healthcare means.
I know that many of you are angry and frustrated that REPUBLICANS! In congress are dragging their feet and trying to block TRUE healthcare reform. What republicans want is just a taxpayer bailout of the DISGRACEFUL GREED DRIVEN PRIVATE FOR PROFIT health insurance industry, and the DISGRACEFUL GREED DRIVEN PRIVATE FOR PROFIT healthcare industry. An insurance bailout is all you really get without a robust government-run public option available on day one.
These industries have been slaughtering you and your loved ones like cattle for decades for profit. Including members of congress and their families. These REPUBLICANS are FOOLS!
Republicans and their traitorous allies have been trying to make it look like it’s President Obama’s fault for the delays, and foot dragging. But I think you all know better than that. President Obama inherited one of the worst government catastrophes in American history from these REPUBLICANS! And President Obama has done a brilliant job of turning things around, and working his heart out for all of us.
But Republicans think you are just a bunch of stupid, idiot, cash cows with short memories. Just like they did under the Bush administration when they helped Bush and Cheney rape America and the rest of the World.
But you don’t have to put up with that. And this is what you can do. The Republicans below will be up for reelection on November 2, 2010. Just a little over 13 months from now. And many of you will be able to vote early. So pick some names and tell their voters that their representatives (by name) are obstructing TRUE healthcare reform. And are sellouts to the insurance and medical lobbyist.
Ask them to contact their representatives and tell them that they are going to work to throw them out of office on November 2, 2010, if not before by impeachment, or recall elections. Doing this will give you something more to do to make things better in America. And it will help you feel better too.
There are many resources on the internet that can help you find people to call and contact. For example, many social networking sites can be searched by state, city, or University. Be inventive and creative. I can think of many ways to do this. But be nice. These are your neighbors. And most will want to help.
I know there are a few democrats that have been trying to obstruct TRUE healthcare reform too. But the main problem is the Bush Republicans. Removing them is the best thing tactically to do. On the other hand. If you can easily replace a democrat obstructionist with a supportive democrat, DO IT!
You have been AMAZING!!! my people. Don’t loose heart. You knew it wasn’t going to be easy saving the World. :-)
God Bless You
jacksmith — Working Class
Republican Senators up for re-election in 2010.
* Richard Shelby of Alabama
* Lisa Murkowski of Alaska
* John McCain of Arizona
* Mel Martinez of Florida
* Johnny Isakson of Georgia
* Mike Crapo of Idaho
* Chuck Grassley of Iowa
* Sam Brownback of Kansas
* Jim Bunning of Kentucky
* David Vitter of Louisiana
* Kit Bond of Missouri
* Judd Gregg of New Hampshire
* Richard Burr of North Carolina
* George Voinovich of Ohio
* Tom Coburn of Oklahoma
* Jim DeMint of South Carolina
* John Thune of South Dakota
* Kay Bailey Hutchison of Texas
* Bob Bennett of Utah
Until Ijoined Second Life five years ago, I hadn’t had miuch contact with people from the US, and I believed the hype that we are fed all the time, that people with insurance in the US get better treatment and care than those of us in the UK. A few months’ contact with fellow residents in Second Life disabused me of that notion. While I can choose which General Practice to register with in my town, and which hospital I want to be treated at, I find that even my friends with insurance get few choices from their insurers. Even worse, people without insurance can’t afford even to send their children to be diagnosed. I can’t imagine how dreadful that must be. There has to be change, and it needs to be now. How can the US have any authority in the world if it will allow its own citizens to sicken and die…and only treat them if they can pay?
Of course, you’re willing to believe that character, right?
.
THINK: He was (and still is) a part of the problem.
.
The problem is BIG PHARMA and BIG GOVERNMENT: THEY WALK HAND-IN-HAND.
.
The poster above —jacksmith— is a bleeding COMMUNOFASCIST.
.
Anyone who think to thieve the lives of others for their own purposes is a BLOODY DAMNED THIEF.
.
All anyone has to do is LOOK BEHIND THE CURTAIN to see that the whole of this is nought but a BIG SCAM run by the very same elitists who’ve been making TRILLIONS of dollars as it is.
.
So, what better way to CONTINUE making TRILLIONS of dollars?
.
Easy! Get the government involved by MANDATING participation in something MOST healthy Americans shy away from: INSURANCE.
.
The post above —jacksmith— wants >YOU< to think that he has a solution.
.
Right.
.
If ENFORCED MISERY is some kind of solution, then a BULLET IN THE HEAD will solve everything he wants to FORCE upon us.
.
Ain't that right, jacksmith?
.
If you can't STEAL other people's money, then STEAL THEIR LIVES.
.
Right, jacksmith?
WTF is highlander talking about? communofascist, I do like the word, nice job on that one mate.
And you might want to drink decaffinated coffee just for a spell, you know, at least until you stop shaking.
“Most healthy Americans shy away from health insurance,” brilliant point there, just brilliant.
It’s easy to disagree with reform. Seems to be a lot of scaremongering going on about a universal heath care system but consider the facts.
41 million Americans do not have heath care coverage.
Translation: The health care system we currently have in place isn’t working.
Solution: Provide Americans with universal health care.
Will this create some inconveniences like line ups at the doctors office?
Absolutely!! ..
Will this cost taxpayers who are not “using” the system money?
Absolutely!!
Does it already cost taxpayers money for “uninsured” people who are using the current system?
Absolutely!!
I suspect that inconvenience of waiting in line is far better than not getting any heath care services at all. It true, there are no lineups at present. However, you can’t simply ignore those many people who need help, who cannot afford to be in the current lineup.
Just like Social Security, a national heath care system is intended for everyone. Funny how people balk at “socialism” yet these are the very same individuals who fully support a national “Social Security” plan. Just like Social Security, a national health care system is intended as a “safety net” paid for by the public, for the public. Takes the “profiteers” out of the picture.
Taxpayers are currently paying $10 for an Aspirin under the current “private insurance” plan. Ever wonder why medicine was so much cheaper in Canada by comparison? … Answer: Taxpayers pay for health care and as such costs are monitored. There is accountability to the people. This is not occurring in the private heath care industry in the US. It is all about profit, not public accountability thus “costs” skyrocket and YOU the taxpayer pays, pays and pays more money until it becomes no longer affordable. This is exactly what is happening to taxpayers.
The “private health care” system doesn’t pay for people who are uninsured. Taxpayers do. When illegal immigrants go to a hospital for treatment, the treatment isn’t free. Some one pays. The difference here is that we have 41 million Americans who don’t have access to health care while illegal immigrants only need to walk into any hospital and get instant access to a wide variety of services at taxpayers expense. Anyone else see something wrong with that picture?
Might as well institute a national health care system. We are already paying for non citizens to use health care in this country. Why not include every American on that list too?
Most people don’t really understand the issues. I think they vote on things based on the kind of car someone drives or the color of someone’s tie.
The fact is. We have 41 million Americans with any “access” to health care. Yes, “access.” In a country like the United States we have 41 million citizens who cannot get medical treatment because they are not covered. That’s a real problem and even if the proposed solution isn’t perfect, “ANY” solution is better than getting nothing at all.
I’lll be glad to wait in line because it’s much better than being sick at home with no money and nowhere to turn for help.
The most important point is that we will probably have to start at the state level, just as Canada started at the provinical level and just as we did with social security. Six states had passed social security before we got it passed on the national level. If we had a Lyndon Johnson and no war around his neck, we probably could get it done on the national level, and could have fun replacing some Republicans and blue-dog Dems next year, but we don’t. We need to focus our attention on the people we are electing to state legislative bodies; if they won’t support single-payer, we don’t support them. Pay attention to both Maine and Colorado —- Massachusetts came so close, but the opposition was fierce and well-funded. Maybe the next governor’s race in California will rest on this issue. By the time we get six states or more, maybe we will have learned to quit electing centrist Dems.