Glenn Beck Promotes Socialism To West Point Cadets

On his show last Friday, Glenn Beck did something quite unusual for a guy who makes his living scaring people into thinking that America is on the road to communism — he promoted an idea straight out of the Paris Commune of 1871, an idea considered by the Commune to be a necessary stepping stone in the transition from capitalism to socialism to communism. And, to make it even more special, Beck did this before a studio audience of West Point cadets and faculty members.

Now, the fact that West Point allowed a group of uniformed academy cadets and faculty to be used as props by Beck is a serious matter in itself, and I’ll get to that in a minute, but Beck, in his zeal to slam Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid, unknowingly promoting a core step towards socialism is just way too ironic to pass up. And what is this step towards socialism that Beck, in all his ignorance, was so enthusiastically promoting? That government employees and officials should never be paid more than what the average citizen earns.

In a 1911 speech about the Paris Commune — a movement lauded by Marx as “heroic,” and said by Lenin to have been “a practical step that was more important than hundreds of programmes and arguments” –Lenin pointed out the Commune’s (and apparently now Glenn Beck’s) position on government salaries: “And, as if to emphasize its character as a truly democratic, proletarian government, the Commune decreed that the salaries of all administrative and government officials, irrespective of rank, should not exceed the normal wages of a worker …” I think maybe that crack research team (or research team on crack) that Beck is always boasting about should have done a bit more research for this show.

Now, back to the other issue with this episode of Beck — the utter impropriety of West Point allowing Beck to use West Point cadets and faculty members for his studio audience.

According to CPT Olivia Nunn of West Point’s Public Affairs office, the cadets and faculty members, all from the academy’s Systems Engineering Department, were visiting the studios of FOX News as an academic exercise “to watch how news productions are done from beginning to end.” The cadets appeared on several other FOX News shows on Thursday, answering questions about why they decided to join the military and their experience at West Point, and the faculty members answered questions about teaching there. All of this was perfectly appropriate. But then, on Friday, they appeared on Beck, which was completely inappropriate. Military personnel in uniform cannot engage in any activity that gives the appearance of supporting any political, religious, or ideological movement.

There is no question that, more than anything else, what Glenn Beck’s show consistently promotes would be classified as an “ideological movement,” fitting the dictionary definition of “ideology” to a tee: “a system of ideas and ideals, esp. one that forms the basis of economic or political theory and policy.” Whatever the specific topic of any given Beck episode — whether it’s history, religion, politics, or just picking someone to bash for weeks on end — all are clearly tied into the promotion of this ideology in one way or another. How can a studio audience full of uniformed West Point cadets and military officer faculty members clapping for Beck’s overtly partisan rant against Congress not be seen as engaging in an activity that gives the appearance of military support for Beck’s “ideological movement?”

As I wrote in a previous post about the problem of Glenn Beck’s show being aired on the American Forces Network, and the complaints received by the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF) about televisions in PXs, gyms, and other facilities on military installations being regularly tuned in to Beck, Article 88 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) — “Contempt toward officials” — states: “Any commissioned officer who uses contemptuous words against the President, the Vice President, Congress, the Secretary of Defense, the Secretary of a military department, the Secretary of Homeland Security, or the Governor or legislature of any State, Commonwealth, or possession in which he is on duty or present shall be punished as a court-martial may direct.”

But on Beck’s show last Friday, during which Beck spewed his typical contempt towards members of Congress, we had eighteen future Army officers, under the guidance of five faculty members — four majors and a lieutenant colonel — clapping on national television for statements that they, as military officers, could be court-martialed for uttering themselves.

As seen in the video above, in addition to being contemptuous towards Congress as a whole, Beck, of course, singled out Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid in his rant about members of Congress whose wealth has increased during the time they’ve been in Congress, even though, according to Roll Call’s 50 Richest Members of Congress list, Pelosi is only at number 13. But the wealthiest member of the House of Representatives is a republican — Darrell Issa of California, whose minimum net worth for 2009, according to Roll Call, was more than seven times the net worth of Pelosi. And Harry Reid? Well, he didn’t even make the top 50. But these pesky facts didn’t stop Beck from insinuating that there’s something suspicious about Pelosi and Reid having money. Exactly what Beck is implying isn’t clear, but his intent certainly is — plant the notion in his audience’s heads that Pelosi and Reid have somehow gotten rich as a result of serving in Congress.

When asked if West Point considered it risky to allow the cadets to appear on a show hosted by someone who is well known to be highly partisan and contemptuous towards the President and Congress, CPT Nunn responded that Glenn Beck had told them that his show would only be about honoring the military for Veterans Day, and they had no way of knowing that he was going to get political. Right. We all know that Glenn Beck would never be less than completely honest.

Now, there actually was one very important federal regulation that West Point was apparently quite concerned about. As Beck pointed out on his November 11 radio show, he wasn’t allowed to spend more that $20 per person when he bought the cadets dinner that night. Obviously, violating that regulation would have been a real problem.

It was pretty clear, however, that Beck just didn’t care that he was crossing a line, beginning the overtly political part of his show by saying “I’m going to try very hard to not get overtly political here because then everybody in the military always says, oh no, oh no, don’t look at me, I neither agree or disagree,” and, towards the end of his little rant, actually laughing about the fact that his captive audience of cadets wasn’t allowed to respond to his political opinions even if they disagreed with them.

Beck also had a few things to say about my previous post, “Should the U.S. Military Be Promoting and Endorsing Glenn Beck?,” on his October 29 radio show:

“Well, we have now — we have now — another attack — and we’ll get into this probably next week — on us, now through the military. ‘Should the U.S. Military Be Promoting and Endorsing Glenn Beck?’ And this is the Military Religious Freedom Foundation, and they’re saying that the military is pushing my religion. Now, it’s not my actual faith, or not my actual religion, but, you know, the religion of Glenn Beck, if you will. Complaints about the program on the televisions in the PXs, the gyms, and other facilities now include complaints that ‘these televisions are being tuned into Fox News’s own evangelist Glenn Beck.’ They’re the usual complaints — ‘one about a senior NCO beginning each day by quoting a bit of Glenn Beck’s wisdom to his subordinates, and telling them they should continue their education by attending Beck’s online university, making their base a satellite Beck University campus.’ And then it just goes on about how evil I am, etc, etc. I think this is fantastic, and if I can find out who this NCO is and this base, we’ll make them an official satellite — a satellite of our Beck University. There’s nothing better. Of course, then again, I’m just a — I’m just a crazy anti-communist.”

No, Mr. Beck, I didn’t just go on about how evil you are. I went on to write that it’s your constant contempt for the President, Congress, and other government officials that makes your show inappropriate to be aired on the American Forces Network, as this kind of contempt against government officials is prohibited in the military. But, I realize that letting your listeners know what the main issue addressed in my post really was might have been a bit awkward, so I’d expect nothing less from you than your complete omission of my main point.

Finally, a note on the numbers Beck used to show how the evil Congress is screwing over the troops. Now, I don’t think anyone would disagree that our troops in the junior enlisted ranks should absolutely be paid more. A private’s starting salary of around $17,000 a year is unconscionably low for someone who’s putting their life on the line for our country.

But Beck’s use of the salary of a specialist with four years service as the “Average U.S. Army” salary, while very effective for his goal making the disparity between military pay, civilian salaries, and federal employee salaries appear as big as possible, is more than a bit deceptive. For one thing, Beck’s “Average U.S. Citizen” income of $50,462 is the median “household” income, not the average individual income.

This figure, of course, includes households with more than one wage earner, making it significantly higher than the average individual income, which, according to the Census Bureau is $39,138. Next, military personnel don’t have the single largest expense that civilian workers do — their housing. If they don’t live in government-provided housing, they receive a Basic Allowance for Housing (BAH), based on the cost of housing where they’re stationed, in addition to their pay. So, the pay for Beck’s example of an E-4 getting out after four years of service would not be $22,676. Their base pay would have been $25,128, plus a BAH of $14,940 if they lived off post and had a family (using Fort Drum’s BAH scale as an example), for a total of $40,068, well above the average income of a high school graduate with four years at a civilian job. If they stay in for a few more years and make staff sergeant, the’ll be up to about $50,000 (again based on Fort Drum’s BAH scale).

If they make a career of it and stay in for twenty years and make first sergeant, they’ll be up to a total of about $75,000 — well above the average civilian income. And what about those future officers in Beck’s studio audience? Well, when they graduate, their base pay of $33,396, plus a BAH of $15,984 (again based on Fort Drum’s scale) if they live off post, would add up to about the same as the average starting salary for a recent college graduate in the civilian world. At the end of their five year active duty commitment, by which time, unless they’re a total screw-up, they’ll have made the rank of captain, their combined salary and BAH will be over $78,000 — more than the average federal employee. And if these cadets decide to make a career of it, and rise to the rank of colonel or one-star general, they’ll be in the $120,000 to $160,000 range. So, yes, something absolutely needs to be done to raise the pay of the lower enlisted ranks, but the income of officers and NCOs is actually well above the average American’s income (and they deserve every penny of it, of course).

The full November 12 Glenn Beck episode can be found here.

Chris Rodda is the Senior Research Director for the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF), and the author of Liars For Jesus: The Religious Right’s Alternate Version of American History.

Article Tools:  Print   Email

10 Responses for “Glenn Beck Promotes Socialism To West Point Cadets”

  1. @SethP23 says:

    It’s funny to me that Beck did not mention how much he makes criticizing how much others make.

  2. steve says:

    because a socialist or communist says “work hard” does not mean it is necessary that a free marketer or capitalist must not agree. Just because Atheism is a cornerstone of communism, does not mean that a capitalist would be confused if he thought that atheism would be good for Capitalism (I certainly believe atheism is good for no one.)
    We should not avoid oranges because Hitler happened to like them ( I have no idea what Hitler thought about citrus fruits.)
    -S W

  3. steve says:

    because a socialist or communist says “work hard” does not mean it is necessary that a free marketer or capitalist must not agree. Just because Atheism is a cornerstone of communism, does not mean that a capitalist would be confused if he thought that atheism would be good for Capitalism (I certainly believe atheism is good for no one.)
    We should not avoid oranges because Hitler happened to like them ( I have no idea what Hitler thought about citrus fruits.)

    And SethP23: why would it be funny that someone makes money who criticizes the amount certain people make; particularly when he is referring to those who “make” no money, but are paid wholly by the money created in the private sector.
    -S W

  4. Johnny America says:

    Americans need to wake up the fact that Beck is simply another opinion pushing charlatan who is a product of mormon cult theology that he mixes with parts of Catholicism and his personal core as a dry alcoholic. And for the record, he is a Mormon and not a Christian. The two are not the same. The religion of Islam has more in common with Christianity than the mormon cult. As someone with a graduate degree in religion, I can say with all qualifications that Mormonism fits all parameters of a cult and has none of the parameters of a religion. A cult is any group (regardless of its size) that interprets the doctrines of a religion in an unorthodox fashion. Cults have come out of all major world religions and Christianity is no exception. The problem here is the fact the most Christians do not understand the difference between the two and they easily fall for the lies of Mormon missionaries or Jehovah’s Witness cultists when they come to one’s door.

    Glenn Beck is a complete total idiot who has no honor, does not support America’s troops and would not know the first thing about restoring honor to the USA. On this idiots radio show and Fox Network program he consistently demonstrates all the unstable behaviors of a dry alcoholic which include grandiosity, judgmentalism, intolerance, impulsivity, ADD and indecisiveness. Alongside that reality, Glenn Beck does not possess a single ounce of journalistic integrity, has no college degree, has no qualifications and he is definitely not a true conservative. But then, what can anyone expect from someone who can’t find anything filthier than their own personal reflection. Since people like Beck cannot survive on the basis of any personal merits, they survive by putting others down with lies and half truths in order to feel good about themselves.

    The truth about Beck is that he a dry mormon alcoholic who never got the counseling required for alcoholics. To further complicate things and confuse people, Beck flippantly throws around Christian terms like “God”, “Jesus”,”Holy Spirit” as well as voices of other so called “Spirit Powers” on his radio talk show. Beck is a mormon in active standing with the mormon church and is not a Christian. Mormonism teaches many gods, that the god of the earth was once a man who attained godhood status, there is no trinity, the cross of Christ means nothing and that Jesus Christ and Satan were brothers. They have some very twisted ideas that do not come from the Christian Bible or Christian doctrines and they are laughing all the way to the bank with each temple they build.

    Because Beck does not possess a single ounce of journalistic integrity, he is the perfect abortion poster child for Fox Network. The people who love what Beck says are no different than the impressionable sheep who loved every speech made by Adolph Hitler in his early years when he brought Germany into an era of economic prosperity These same sheep also blindly followed Hitler into one of the darkest chapters of world history. Beck and the Fox Network both cater to the same lowest common denominator of demagoguery.
    Someone should have asked Beck which of the many mormon gods he kept talking about during his argument with himself on Saturday on the square in DC. Like a typical dry alcoholic, Beck even lied on national television when he spoke about holding a document signed by George Washington. That event never took Place. Unfortunately, people who love being led around by the nose do not realize that Beck is talking about a different god than that of Christianity, Judaism or Islam.

    Beck has been a product of mormon cultism from the day he started doing a radio talk show as an opinion pusher. This idiot never even went to college, has no clue what is really in the US Constitution or what the founding fathers really believed and intended. You don’t have to have a degree in psychology to see that Beck exhibits all the signs of a dry alcoholic. The only reason this unstable impressionable idiot fell into mormonism was because the woman he wanted to have sex with would not do so unless they got first got married and joined a church. From that point, they joined the mormon cult where Beck’s unstable mind went even further out into left field through mixing Catholicism with mormonism. Glenn Beck is as big a charlatan as Joseph Smith or that 5th grade graduate (Charles T Russell) who started the Jehovah’s Witness cult.
    This is Glenn Beck in a very accurate and concise nutshell. Considering the fact that Becks personal views are extreme Marxist Libertarian, his form of patriotism is false and he is a person who has no real substance or depth. It will not surprise many of us when Beck’s next big thing is to come out of the closet and announce his homosexuality to the nation. Simply put…he is just another predatory neocon who is pushing the buttons of very ignorant & impressionable people who love being told what to think and believe.

    We live in a period of history where it has become very socially acceptable to be stupid and follow extremist idiots like Glenn Beck, Adolph Hitler, Sarah Palin, Karl Rove, Dick Cheney, Christine O Donnell and Rush Limbaugh. Chicanery and lies are their middle names as these people have no ounce of integrity and are masters at perverting truth, facts and history. Even now…Beck is probably masturbating while watching Fox News video footage of Christine O Donnell & Sarah Palin while brainstorming over his next round of vile spew for his opinion pushing points on the radio or TV.

  5. Jack Sparrow says:

    It’s not the base pay that’s the killer, it’s all the retirement benefits that public employees get. This is what is bringing state gov’ts close to insolvency.

    Taking the counter argument, if we pay public employees too little, it’s possible that they will try to make up the difference through corruption.

  6. Vang Veets says:

    OK this makes a whole lotta sense dude.


  7. Jeff says:

    No, and as usual you take everything completely out of context. Public servants should not make almost double the income of an average US citizen, and setting limits on a wage provided by tax dollars is not socialism.

    The wage of a congressman is not determined by supply and demand as a properly functioning economic structure does. The wages of public servants should be decided by the people who elect them to their positions, not the people holding the positions.

  8. Glenn Beck and Fox is the fox in the hen house. This media lie is leading this country to destruction with the fair and balance lie. How is it that you spend all you time finding fault and digging in the dirt of humanity. Then turn around and air it is news, as fair and balance and unafraid. God Sees and knows All. (Matthew 6:1-8) How do these human the dig in this dirt and and hate of it brothers and sisters sleep at night. Look their is not a day that go by that the fox has something to say that is good on a continue basis about anybody. I would like to see the collection of dirt information on the President that is collected as news then they pick out every day something to say negative about the Leader of the nation, how can that be helpful to it’s people. They are all good at it to. The reporter Shepard Smith is some daylight his information and has a sense of fairness.

  9. empirical collapse says:

    becks an idiot, but to be fair, obama deserves constant contempt, more so than bush, because for all of bushes faults, he didnt pretend he was going to be anything different.

  10. reallyrogue says:

    Shoot, Glenn’s just showin’ off that high school ejucashun of his!

Leave a Reply

Article Tools:  Print   Email
Copyright © 2008 The Public Record. All rights reserved. Branding services provided by www.AndrewToschi.com Quantcast